Essie Forever Yummy vs Really Red: Which is the Ultimate Red for You?
The Initial Impressions: When You’re Staring at the Bottles
Walking down the nail polish aisle, these two reds seem similar at first glance. Forever Yummy exudes a deep, sophisticated vibe. It’s a true red that seems like it could transition from the office to a night out effortlessly. On the other hand, Really Red feels a bit more on the classic, vibrant side, reminiscent of Old Hollywood glamour. It’s striking, and immediately catches your attention.
- Essie Forever Yummy: This shade is a rich, deep cherry red. It's for the person who loves a red that feels luxurious, classy, and timeless. It gives off an understated confidence—a red that says, “I’ve got this, without trying too hard.”
- Essie Really Red: This, on the other hand, is a more flamboyant, in-your-face type of red. It’s brighter, more vivid, and if there were a nail polish equivalent of a red lipstick, this would be it. It’s the kind of red you’d imagine Marilyn Monroe would wear.
How They Wear
But first impressions aren’t everything. You’ve got to know how they hold up on your nails. Both formulas are part of Essie’s main line, which means you’re getting a top-notch product no matter which you choose. But let’s break down the experience of each:
Forever Yummy:
- Longevity: This red is long-lasting. Its formula is slightly thicker, providing great opacity in just one coat. However, with two coats, it becomes the epitome of perfection. It dries quickly, but not too fast, allowing you to smooth out any mistakes.
- Finish: The finish is glossy, but more on the elegant side of shine rather than blinding. It's subtle, which works well for someone who loves the understated glamour.
- Chip Resistance: It has excellent chip resistance. A week of wear, even with the occasional dishwashing or keyboard typing, and Forever Yummy barely shows any signs of wear and tear.
Really Red:
- Longevity: Equally impressive in terms of longevity, but it’s slightly thinner in consistency compared to Forever Yummy. This means you might need two coats for full opacity. However, once applied, it lasts just as long.
- Finish: The shine on Really Red is more intense. It’s high-gloss, almost lacquer-like, which can be great if you’re aiming for a more striking look.
- Chip Resistance: Similar to Forever Yummy, it’s highly durable. A week goes by and this polish looks freshly applied. However, because it's thinner, it might chip slightly easier if you’re rough with your hands.
Skin Tone and Red: A Match Made in Heaven?
Choosing between Forever Yummy and Really Red might come down to your skin tone. While both shades look stunning, they interact with different undertones in unique ways.
Fair Skin: If you have fair skin, Really Red is your friend. Its bright, bold nature contrasts beautifully against pale skin, making it pop without looking too harsh. Forever Yummy can work too, but its deeper tone might feel a bit too muted if you're aiming for a brighter aesthetic.
Medium/Olive Skin: This is where Forever Yummy shines. Its richness complements the warmth in medium skin tones, creating a harmonious look. Really Red can still be a good choice, but it’s likely to feel more intense on medium or olive complexions.
Dark Skin: Both shades look incredible on darker skin tones, but for different reasons. Really Red provides a striking contrast that is sure to turn heads, while Forever Yummy feels more sultry, blending seamlessly for a more subtle, sophisticated look.
Occasion Matters
When are you wearing this red polish? That could be the deciding factor.
Everyday Wear: Forever Yummy is more versatile. It’s the kind of red you can wear to the office without it being distracting. It’s bold enough to make a statement but not so in-your-face that it feels out of place in a professional setting.
Night Out: Really Red is your go-to for a night out. It’s vibrant, fun, and demands attention. Paired with a little black dress, it becomes the ultimate accessory.
Special Events: Both colors are perfect for weddings, galas, or any formal event. The choice between them is purely based on the statement you want to make—Forever Yummy for understated elegance, Really Red for glamorous drama.
A Deeper Dive: Comparing the Ingredients and Formula
To truly understand the difference between these two polishes, let’s take a look at the formulas:
| Polish | Formula | Thickness | Longevity | Opacity | Dry Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Forever Yummy | Traditional 3-free formula | Thicker | High | 1-2 coats | Medium |
| Really Red | Traditional 3-free formula | Thinner | High | 2 coats | Fast |
Both use Essie’s traditional 3-free formula, meaning they’re free from formaldehyde, toluene, and DBP. However, the application experience differs because of the slight difference in consistency.
Forever Yummy feels more substantial with each stroke, providing a smoother, more even application in fewer coats. Really Red is lighter, more fluid, which can make it trickier to apply, but it dries faster, making it a better option if you’re short on time.
Final Verdict: Which Red Should You Choose?
So, which one should you go for? It really depends on what you're looking for:
If you want a timeless red that works for any occasion and complements a wide range of skin tones, Forever Yummy is your best bet. It's a polish that you can wear from the office to a date night, always looking chic and polished.
If you're after something more vibrant, bold, and playful, Really Red is perfect. This is the red for when you want to make a statement, to draw attention, and to show off your glamorous side.
Ultimately, both of these Essie reds are winners in their own right. But whether you choose Forever Yummy or Really Red, you’ll be stepping out in style with nails that command attention.
Top Comments
No Comments Yet